Devonta Smith or Brian Thomas Jr?

I know on all trade calcs itll easily be smith, but idk i feel like its close

Give me BTJ just for upside alone.

Yea it’s the upside for me. Smitty seems kinda capped

I wouldnt bet on it but Puca came outta nowhere n did it

Jj wasn't top wr drafted Un his year

Don’t get suckered into the rookie fever @Adam11534 BTJ is good but I wouldn’t say he’s special and in an offense that will continue to spread the ball around

But I'm not gonna critisize

His opinion

Gotcha

On team or as in a top 10 WR @ESPN4Lyfe ?

Yeah won’t argue against that at all

Smith

This is for dynasty btw. I feel like if he’s WR1 on the jaguars then he will indeed shine in a couple years; this is the piece tlaw needs

But smith has a top 10 season so didn’t understand the upside point

Smitty. Obviously

I don’t think smith will put up another top 10 season though

That’s fair

@Steven appreciate the input

BTJ is like the wr 5 in rookie drafts rn lmao

DEVONTA

Smith everyday of the week

Smitty not close.

I mean the value lies with Smith atm. He’s a sure thing and rookies are not. if you are trading smith for BTJ, you need to sweeten the pot. That being said, I WANT BTJ for 2 reasons and you need to believe them both for him to be better than smith. 1) I still believe in TLaw emerging into a super star and reestablishing his 1st overall draft capital. 2) I believe that BTJ can improve routes and is a more multidimensional WR than displayed at LSU.