Send: Waddle + 2025 2nd Receive: Olave + 2026 3rd Yay or Nay?

Devonte and olave are pretty much equal in my eyes

No. Olave has all the talent in the world, but he's a distant second to Waddle because of underwhelming QB play.

No

2025 2nd, that is.

I don’t think there is much of difference between Olave and Devonta. That being said, if Olave is your guy, I’d trade Devonta and a 3rd, but I think the 2nd is too much @KakeJelley

@KakeJelley I'd also rather have Devonta Smith over Olave. But value wise they should be pretty much equal IMO. If you really wanted Olave I'd be willing to give up a 3rd on top of Smith for it but I personally would rather have Smith

The biggest problem with Olave isn't about him. Derek Carr is allergic to the end zone, thereby lowering the fantasy value of his WRs. I would take DeVonta Smith over Olave ten times out of ten.

waddle