Purdy or Penix in dynasty?
Purdy
Purdy but penix is more exciting so I’d trade penix for Purdy plus if you can
ill take the risk on Penix given his core
Don't think these two are that far apart from Penix is the unknown so people are going to lean more towards him
Valuewise it’s Penix. In realized value, I don’t think there’s much difference. So as mentioned, I’d be fine taking Purdy+ for Penix
Purdy
purdy
Purdy
Need more than just a handful of game sample
Penix
Anyone saying Purdy is either a delusional 9ers fan or doesn’t know that the 9ers are in full rebuild mode. He was pulled at the end of the season for a backup because he had an injured throwing arm at the exact same spot Hassan Reddick injured him in the playoffs against the Eagles, and the 9ers are trying to sell Aiyuk now too. I would avoid Purdy like the plague because even if he doesn’t have any phantom health problems he won’t have receivers to throw to, and even then his passing game literally only ever works when he has an elite run game making defenses sell out
I would take Penix, younger supporting cast of weapons, bigger arm, plus 49ers looking to offload as many of those contracts as possible, so might have even less weapons next year