Boys I am in a pickle, needing to grab my 2nd QB for superflex. Do I get Geno, Carr, Rodgers or Fields? I hate asking lol

Rodgers

Rodgers or Carr

Fields shouldn’t be in the discussion, imo

He’s always been that dude.

Would you still do it for Dynasty

Assuming dynasty you’re getting 1 year out of Rodgers, probably 1 out of geno (I think Howell takes over tbh), maybe a few out of Carr (but I’ve always been super low on him) and potentially nothing out of fields

None are great options but I’d say for just this year Rodgers is the only one w upside. Maybe Carr plays well enough for an extension. So I’d pick one of those two guys

You’re considering grabbing a backup QB as your QB2?

Geno

I'd probably go Rodgers

He’s dog shit

rodgers

Geno, Rodgers, Carr, Fields my order

Geno

Geno

Rodgers

Rodgers or Geno, Fields worth a stash though in case he takes the job

Lean geno

Not fields. Leaning Carr because Olave went over 1k last year and Kamara had 57 receptions. Geno inconsistent. IMO

Geno, Fields, Carr, Rodgers -- only thing that has me leaning Geno is uncertainty if Fields will start.

As a bears fan, fields is one of the worst passers I’ve ever seen in my life. Russ ain’t what he used to be but he’s still an okay enough bridge starter. Fields is a running back that’s asked to throw passes and he just stares at open receivers with a blank stupid look on his face before deciding to scramble because his brain can’t process how to throw a ball

If you actually watch fields play QB and think he has any sort of potential, you need to be lobotomized

That’s a tough one but it is what it is. Honestly in terms of 1-2 years of short term service to buy you time… not Fields. I would be happy enough any of the other three as quick cheap fixes. Geno, Rodgers, Carr in that order. Is Kirk Cousins available… I’m in a win now league needing a second QB. I traded 1.12, 3.12 and late 2025 3rd for Kirk Cousins and Christian Kirk…