Who is the most overrated player in baseball?

Ohtani by far

Aaron Judge by far

Soto

or Elly

Every Met

Soto Elly and Ohtani

Bo Bichette

jazz

if you say ohtania you are not wring but he is also not the worst

Soto after that albatross of a contract. He's been clutch but not dominant

Your mother

Juan Soto

Juan Soto and Elly da la cruiz

Elly for sure

Tatis

Ima dodgers fan saying that

aaron jurdte

Pete Alonso

Give me any Yankees player

Pete Alonso he is fat

Truly overrated - pick any of the last 5 years of “hype” guys coming into the league. Currently Jackson Holiday is over-rated, meaning he’s getting more credit than he’s earned…. But don’t confuse that with the fact that his potential is still there. He is (by media) overrated…. But he also has years to prove himself. I think as far as vets, it’s gotta be Trout. Played in a cake division year after year and crushed mediocre pitchers.

Adolis Garcia

2 years ago